Nepo-hire project manager tries to outwit his engineer, leading to a construction site failure that costs millions, engineer provides email receipts to prove his innocence to management: ‘He was sacked… Even his uncle couldn’t save him'

Author image for Jesse Kessenheimer
Jesse Kessenheimer • Writer and Editor
Mar 22, 2025 6:00 PM EDT

On the job site, always trust your engineer. 

Contrarily, this nepo-hire project manager only trusted himself and it was wholly misplaced. Without any knowledge of the scientific specifics, he decided to make a unilateral decision that would cost a lot more than a few lost days on the job—it would cost his company millions in damages, time, rebuilds, and ultimately, his career. 

In my opinion, it serves someone right to pay the price when they've overstepped their wheelhouse. Especially when we're talking about potentially dangerous, life-threatening scenarios on a construction site, safety measures and failsafes are not to be trifled with. Likely driven by ego, this hot-headed personality hire was severely punished for being a total dingus—and rightfully so. 

Advertisement

  • Lessons were learned in this next tale of blue-collar retribution, where it's truly a miracle that nobody was hurt. Luckily for the smart and hardworking crew on this site, they were unshackled from the dimwittedness of a nepotism hire who had no business setting foot in a pair of construction boots. Keep scrolling for the entire story, with each juicy twist and turn, that'll ultimately lead to the demise of a guy who totally deserved everything that hit him.

  • Cheezburger Image 10483482624
    via ckstockphoto

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • Back when I was a junior engineer, I was working with a piping contractor supporting a gas plant project that was in the final stretch before commissioning. We were
    via RearEngineer
  • under intense pressure to hit deadlines, and everyone was feeling the heat. One of my responsibilities was reviewing materials before installation, i.e. basic quality control to make sure we weren't about
    via RearEngineer
  • to install something that would bite us later. Then the pipes arrived. These were large-diameter, high-pressure pipes for a critical gas line. But the
    via RearEngineer
  • moment I saw them, I knew something was off. The mill markings didn't match the material certificates, and some of the weld seams looked rough. When we took a closer look, we found surface
    via RearEngineer
  • defects and laminations at the bevel, classic signs of poor- quality steel from a dodgy mill. I flagged it immediately. My lead engineer took one look
    via RearEngineer
  • and agreed - these pipes weren't fit for purpose. We raised it with the project manager, expecting him to do the obvious thing, that is to reject the batch and order replacements from an approved supplier.
    via RearEngineer
  • Cheezburger Image 10483482880
    via ckstockphoto

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • But this PM wasn't like most project managers. He wasn't an engineer, had a Bachelor of Commerce and had landed the job thanks to his uncle, a senior executive. He had zero
    via RearEngineer
  • technical knowledge and didn't care to learn. To him, just another job to push through quickly to up his bonus, and rejecting the pipes would cause delays
    via RearEngineer
  • something he was desperate to avoid since it would probably affect his bonus. His response? "The supplier says they meet spec, so they meet spec. Just install them and move on."
    via RearEngineer
  • I pushed back, explaining that if these pipes failed under pressure, we were looking at a major incident. He waved me off.
    via RearEngineer
  • "Just get it done. If it's a problem, the pressure test will catch it." Alright, mate. Let's see how that goes.
    via RearEngineer
  • The pipes were installed as- is, and we moved on to pressure testing. I stood back and watched.
    via RearEngineer
  • As we ramped up the pressure, the pipe's weld seam split wide open and ruptured the pipe. The force of the failure sent a shockwave through the system, and a few of the pipe supports even bent.
    via RearEngineer
  • The pressure test failed. Spectacularly. Now, instead of a minor delay to replace the pipes before installation, we had a catastrophic failure that shut down work for weeks. The
    via RearEngineer
  • entire line had to be cut out, re- welded, and re-tested. The supplier was blacklisted, and an internal investigation was launched into how the pipes had been approved in the first
    via RearEngineer
  • place. We were also made by the client to bear the cost of rework. As expected, the PM tried to shift the blame. But my lead engineer simply pulled up the
    via RearEngineer
  • email chain where we had clearly raised the defect concerns. Management didn't take long to connect the dots. The PM was taken off the
    via RearEngineer
  • project immediately and was sacked a month later following initial investigation results and even his uncle couldn't save him. Never saw him again after that and last I heard he decided to pursue a career outside of the industry.
    via RearEngineer
  • AppropriateRip9996 I wouldn't put him in charge of sandwich bread. Two teens on the line say the bread is stale and moldy. Let's see if the customers complain.
    via AppropriateRip9996
  • Craig_White. As an engineering manager who once was the junior and senior engineer himself, if someone raises a red flag I push the stop button until at least three people, including the one that raised the red flag in the first place, prove to me we are good to go.
    via Craig_White
  • Flight_of_Elpenor I am glad to hear you had the email chain! I was hoping the uncle would suffer some consequences, too. I think the uncle is a bigger problem. I am sure he has more loser relatives and friends he can hire.
    via Flight_of_Elpenor
  • NotPrepared2 ...we moved on to pressure testing. I stood back and watched. Hopefully stood WAY back, behind safety glass.
    via NotPrepared2
  • ChimoEngr I expect that everyone was outside the potential danger area of a pipe bursting because safety regs, but I really hope extra care was taken that time to ensure that no one was anywhere near those pipes.
    via ChimoEngr
  • Reclusive Chemist Well, he was right about the pressure test finding any issues. The fact that he didn't understand the potential ramifications of that test failure points out why he should have never been in that position to begin with.
    via Reclusive_Chemist

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

nepotism boss worker employee manager job nepo hire work coworkers working ceo employees supervisor workplace company coworker business
Scroll Down For The Next Article