Well-meaning 28-year-old woman starts storing neighbor's packages in her apartment while he is away on trips, he confronts her for crossing his boundaries: “I was just trying to help; I wasn't snooping”

Advertisement
  • 01

    AITA for bringing my neighbors packages inside my apartment because I was worried they'd get stolen?

    Cheezburger Image 10509673472
  • 02
    I (28F) live in a mid-rise apartment building in the city. We don't have a front desk or package lockers- just a narrow hallway where all deliveries get dumped. If you're not home within a few hours, good luck.
  • 03
    My across-the-hall neighbor, Marcus (30s? late 20s? I honestly don't know), gets a lot of packages. Fancy ones too-clothing boxes with brand names, curated subscription kits, expensive-looking stuff. I'm not
  • 04
    trying to spy or anything, but when you live in close quarters, you notice these things. I'd occasionally see boxes just sitting out overnight while he was clearly out of town, which made me anxious on his behalf.
  • 05
    Cheezburger Image 10509677568
  • 06
    About six weeks ago, I heard him swearing in the hall and went out to see what was wrong. He said one of his packages-some cologne he'd ordered-got
  • 07
    stolen. He looked genuinely upset and mentioned it wasn't the first time. I said something like, "Man, this building really needs lockers or something." He nodded but didn't push it.
  • 08
    So after that, I started bringing his deliveries inside my apartment whenever I noticed they'd been sitting for more than a few hours. Just to be safe. I stacked them in a corner near my front door and gave them back when I saw him. Usually, he just said thanks and took them. No big conversation.
  • 09
    Cheezburger Image 10509677056
  • 10
    Then last week, he knocked and asked me to stop. He wasn't ride about it, but he looked super uncomfortable. He said he appreciated the intention,
  • 11
    but it made him uneasy to know his stuff was in someone else's apartment. He added that it felt like I was "tracking his movements" since I always seemed to know when he wasn't home.
  • 12
    I was kind of stunned. I explained that I was just trying to help-that I wasn't snooping, I just saw stuff piling up. He said, "I get it, but... yeah, it crosses a line. Please don't touch my packages anymore."
  • 13
    I said okay, and he left. But now I feel weird. I genuinely thought I was doing a good deed. I wasn't opening his stuff, just holding it for a few hours until he got back. It's not like I was rifling through his mail.
  • 14
    But then it got more awkward. A few days ago I saw him through his peephole (yes, I was walking to my door, not lurking lol), and he literally waited until I went back inside before he came out to grab his box. Like he's timing it now?
  • 15
    Then this morning, I overheard him talking to another neighbor while checking his mail. He said something like, "Yeah, some people think doing favors means ignoring boundaries." I don't know he meant me, but... it felt pointed.
  • 16
    Now I'm second-guessing everything. I told my sister and she said it was "weirdly possessive" and that I should've just left a note asking if he wanted help next time. But I never thought it would turn into this.
  • 17
    So... AITA for taking matters into my own hands when I thought I was doing something neighborly? Would love honest thoughts because now I feel like I'm the hallway psycho.
  • 18
    Cheezburger Image 10509676800
  • 19
    Plantain Real3396 NTA but slightly leaning toward a soft YTA only because of the whole "doing something helpful without asking" thing. Your intentions were obviously
  • 20
    good, and honestly, most people would appreciate someone looking out for their stuff especially in a building where packages vanish. But yeah, you crossed a boundary without realizing it, and that's the part that made it feel off to him.
  • 21
    It's not that you were being creepy, but from his point of view, it might've started to feel like surveillance, even if that's not what you were doing. The moment someone starts feeling like their privacy's being invaded, even unintentionally, it's hard to unsee it.
  • 22
    That said, you owned up, respected his request, and clearly didn't mean harm. You're not the hallway psycho. Just someone who tried to be helpful in a way that didn't land right and now you know.
  • 23
    dunkdeboffin1 OP Thanks for this genuinely. That was a really thoughtful take and actually helped me see it more from his side. I think I got too caught up in the "I'm helping!" mindset and didn't realize how it might feel like low-key surveillance, even if that wasn't the vibe I meant to give off.
  • 24
    I'm glad I respected the boundary once he set it, but yeah... definitely a lesson learned about asking first instead of assuming. Appreciate the kindness in your comment too - makes it easier to take in without getting defensive haha
  • 25
    feeen1ks Yes, NTA but it would have been more appropriate to ask first. I have a neighbor that I hold packages for and he's done the same for me if I'm out of town, but we had a conversation about it first.
  • 26
    TaffyPetalWink Exactly. OP wasn't being shady they were just trying to help in a way that accidentally crossed a line. It's easy to miss how that might feel from the other side until someone says it. But they listened, backed off, and that says everything about their intentions.
  • 27
    Mermaidstudio Yeah... soft YTA. You meant well, but it was crossing a line. Should've just asked first. Now it feels sneaky and controlling. Let it go and don't bring it up again
  • 28
    NeatNefariousness1 Agreed. Being THAT vigilant about someone else's packages is a bit overboard even though it's well- intentioned.
  • 29
    If it were me, I wouldn't want to wonder if I have packages sitting in my neighbor's house, wouldn't want them looking at what companies I am getting packages from and wouldn't want to have to knock on their door to see what packages they might have picked up from my doorstep.
  • 30
    Wanting to force your "goodwill" gestures on people who don't want them and having trouble accepting the boundaries they've set makes me lean toward a YTA judgment. You seem to be a good person, OP. But let it go. No lasting harm has been done. Live and learn.

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article