28-year-old boyfriend refuses to let girlfriend move into his rent-free apartment when she demands they split utilities based on their income: "I would actually be paying more than I do now"

Author image for Briana Viser
Briana Viser • Writer and Editor
Jun 13, 2025 3:00 PM EDT

Living with a partner is the first step to building a life together. And for people who think they've "lived with their partner" without signing a lease, they're sorely mistaken. Just because you spend every night together, your clothes are there, your books, your toothbrush, and your food, doesn't mean you "live" together. Signing a lease, moving in, planning, decorating, dealing with landlords or other tenants together, it's completely different. 

Knowing you have the option of sleeping in your own place also drastically changes the dynamic. There's an immediate energetic shift when you both decide on moving in together. The prospects of breaking up become less possible in a fluid way. You bank on each other more, you have to be equally responsible in the home, and you have to be aligned in your finances. Now everything is shared, and there's no option to move out unless you break up (usually). Break ups are hard enough, but to break up and now be homeless is an entirely different ballpark. I don't wish it on anyone. 

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • 01

    AITA for telling my girlfriend that we are not living together if she wants to split joint expenses proportional to income?

    Cheezburger Image 10516632320
    via TITOVA ILONA from ilonakozhevnikova / Canva

    This image is for illustration only, and the subjects are models; the image does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 02
    I (28M) met my GF two years ago. My GF is in grad school and lives off of the small stipend she receives and student loans. I make fairly good money.
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460

  • Be careful not to move in too quickly. I have so many friends who jumped into living with their boyfriend, and let me tell you how it never ended well. Even if they dated for years, it's so difficult to move out and break up.

  • 03
    My GF wants to move in with me. I live in a house owned by my grandparents and do not pay rent (at their insistence). My GF's
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 04
    current rent alone takes up almost her entire stipend each month. Plus she has a utilities, food, medical insurance, car insurance, car payment, medical
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 05
    bills, credit card debt, etc. The landlord is raising rent and she has not been able to find a cheaper place that feels moderately safe and sizable
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 06
    Cheezburger Image 10516631808
    via hikesterson from Getty Images Pro / Canva

    This image is for illustration only, and the subjects are models; the image does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 07
    enough for her and her dog. So, she wants to move in with me.
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 08
    I currently have a close friend who also lives here. He pays all the utilities as his rent. My GF wants him to move out if she moves in, which he is fine with
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 09
    doing. I have talked to my GF and stated that if she moves in, we should split the joint bills and expenses 50/50. She is greatly opposed to doing that and thinks
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 10
    it should be proportional. That would result in me paying virtually all the joint expenses. A 50/50 split would result in a
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 11
    significantly better financial situation for her. Right now, her living expenses are exponentially higher than her stipend. With this
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 12
    50/50 split, they would be significantly less than her stipend. I would actually be paying more than I do now with a 50/50 split
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 13
    because I do not pay any utilities right now.
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 14
    I told her if she insists on a proportional split, then we cannot live together. She is ped and says I am causing her
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 15
    unnecessary stress. We both can afford the proportional split so that is what we should do.
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 16
    AITA? Clarification It seems a lot of assumptions are being made in the comments, so I need to clarify some things.
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 17
    1. Yes, I do love my girlfriend, but I have significant disagreements with her on money. Our biggest fights have been about money.
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 18
    Rent Due
    via AndreyPopov from Getty Images / Canva

    This image is for illustration only, and the subjects are models; the image does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 19
    Every summer, she takes a trip somewhere and puts it on a credit card. Last year, she bought a new car. She has a $700/month car
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 20
    payment that her mom has to help her out with. We have talked about these things. She gets defensive and tells me that I have no say over her money.
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 21
    2. I am all about saving. I own a small contracting/construction company with a buddy. We started it not long before I
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 22
    met my GF. In fact, met her because I was doing some renovation work in her apartment complex.
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 23
    Basically, we are pinching pennies for the next couple of years to build up our nest egg and hire a staple of people. So, every dollar counts.
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 24
    3. If we were truly pooling our resources together, I would be ok with proportional. But, that is not what we are doing. My GF wants me to
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 25
    still have no say over how she spends money while doing a proportional expense setup. That is a problem for me.
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Feed460
  • 26
    F1DL5TYX 15h ago My gf is a nurse and makes more than I do, which is a nice change for me. She makes good money and in
    via u/F1DL5TYX
  • 27
    some but not all ways her taste reflects that, and i respect it as it is her money. The arrangement we have is we split things 50/50 when usage is equal, think internet
    via u/F1DL5TYX
  • 28
    and utilities. But we moved into a place that is nicer and more expensive than what I would have been fine with. So we pay proportional rent
    via u/F1DL5TYX
  • 29
    based on income. The same is true for activities/trips. It's an even split unless it's something more expensive than what I would have gone for otherwise, at her
    via u/F1DL5TYX
  • 30
    behest. Then she pays a higher percentage of the cost. We are both reasonable people, we love and respect each other, and thus far it's worked out very well.
    via u/F1DL5TYX

Tags

income drama toxic relationships lol couples love entitled family reddit thread Reddit funny money dating
Scroll Down For The Next Article