"You're financially irresponsible": Parents withhold $130,000 from daughter's bank account despite it being rightfully hers, she grapples with what to do

Advertisement
  • 01

    AITAH for asking my parents for the money they stole from my insurance settlement and then lied about?

    Cheezburger Image 10525453056
  • 02
    I (25F) got into a car accident with my family (mom, dad, and younger brother) which paralyzed me from the waist down when I was 15. My mom broke her femur and some ribs. My dad had a
  • 03
    minor concussion and my brother had some minor abdominal bruising and was never admitted to the hospital. The accident was
  • 04
    caused 100% by the other driver and as a result, led to an insurance settlement when I was 16.
  • 05
    The community I lived in at the time was very generous and donated about $35k to help with my medical bills. I was also very
  • 06
    fortunate to receive top of the line rehab at a couple out of state hospitals, and I'm sure cost quite a bit. My maternal grandparents also donated a ton of money to
  • 07
    this rehab (probably close to $15k if I had to estimate). Since then my parents paid for my college with a 529 plan already established long before I was
  • 08
    paralyzed. Thanks to the great medical care and college, I now live independently, work a decent job, and can afford all my bills for now.
  • 09
    Because the driver who caused the accident was just an individual rather than a company, my parents elected not to sue the
  • 10
    individual and to just take the auto insurance settlement. The problem is, my parents have changed their story about the
  • 11
    settlement money countless times. At first they said all the money—including the portion of the settlement that didn't belong to me would go into some
  • 12
    investment account that I could access at their discretion if I ever needed medical care. Then a couple years later when I was 19 and my brother was 17, they
  • 13
    Cheezburger Image 10525458944
  • 14
    purchased a second house down the road from them intended for my brother. My dad did it sort of impulsively but they justified to me saying they had spent a lot of
  • 15
    money on my medical bills and it wasn't fair that my younger brother hadn't received as much time, money, or attention out of
  • 16
    the whole ordeal. They rented it out for 4 years at a loss while my brother was in school.
  • 17
    Meanwhile, I moved out on my own to another state immediately after graduating college and have been paying all of my own bills ever since.
  • 18
    Fast forward to today, my brother has lived in the house for a year but it turns out they weren't planning to give him the house for free like they originally said.
  • 19
    00 THE OF THE UNITED STATES OFAMERICA IN GOD WE TRUST FGathen of the Tony D 1230C 100 VE NOTE D HE D STATES RICA fe 471 100 TWC 254 FEDERAL RESERVE NOTE LF 59498772 F F6 OT UNITED STATES SYST CCCORD ПРЕССО INDENCE HALL ONE HUNDRED DO ONE BUDRED DOLLARS THE UNITED STATES OFAMERICA DEBTS GAL PUBLIC ANDER FOR A NOTE JULY 4. 1776 te C AND PRIVATE 100 love bunstific 00 ML 22181748F 22 DOLLARS 100 06 STON, D.C
  • 20
    Apparently they wanted him to pay back the mortgage on it which he can't afford. He is now moving back in with them.
  • 21
    I assumed the insurance settlement money had all been spent, but about a week ago my mom said they had "discovered" another medical account and that
  • 22
    I could just ask them if I ever needed medical supplies and they would reimburse me. I asked if I could just have control over the money to invest for myself and
  • 23
    how much money was there. It turns out the entirety of the insurance settlement for all my family members had been put tax-free in my mom's universal
  • 24
    life insurance policy on the advice of their financial advisor. They said they didn't know how much money was there but that they planned to give me $10k/year for
  • 25
    medical expenses and after they pass away they plan to make my brother in charge of distributing those funds to me. When I asked why they hadn't been doing that for the past few years, they
  • 26
    claimed I was "financially irresponsible." My credit score is over 750, I have lived on my own since age 21, I've never missed a payment, I religiously track all expenses and income on
  • 27
    spreadsheets, I've never carried a balance on my credit card, and my partner and I have a net worth of over $40k. I understand I could
  • 28
    theoretically do better, but I have never given anyone any reason to believe I was financially irresponsible.
  • 29
    Initially I was thrilled but my partner was skeptical because my parents have changed their story about this money so many times. So I did some digging on the court cases to find that my
  • 30
    parents had been appointed as my guardians by the court to manage my $130,000 settlement until I became an adult. My brother also received a $30,000 settlement. So this money has
  • 31
    been commingled and was put in my parents' investment account rather than a trust or a UGMA account for me.
  • 32
    I'm thinking of asking my parents and their financial advisor to correct their errors in the most tax-advantaged way possible because I no longer trust them. I plan to ask them to transfer to
  • 33
    me the $130,000 plus any unrealized capital gains that have accumulated over the past 7 years. Considering the average performance of the S&P500 over the past 7 years, that $130,000
  • 34
    should have more than doubled and $10k/year they promised would still allow them to profit off of my own insurance settlement for my spinal cord injury.
  • 35
    I'm tired of my insurance settlement being in their fickle hands and I don't trust them to have my best interest in mind. I want to invest this money in a Roth IRA for my inevitable medical expenses I will have as I age as a wheelchair user.
  • 36
    If they don't voluntarily comply, would I have a decent legal case against them? And AITAH for asking for this money as a lump sum?

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article