'He’s not my dad': 28-year-old bride refuses to let older sister's boyfriend walk her down the aisle in their late dad's place, sister accuses her of dishonoring dad's memory

Author image for Bar Mor Hazut
Bar Mor Hazut • Senior Editor
Aug 10, 2025 12:00 PM EDT

The person who you want to walk you down the aisle should be chosen by more than just the familial relationship you two have. Sure, a dad is the traditional choice, but it doesn't have to be him if you don't feel like it. After all, it's your wedding, and you should get full control when deciding who gets to walk beside you on one of the happiest moments in your life.

When I got married, I wanted both my parents to be by my side as I walked down the aisle, and that is exactly what happened. I also attended countless weddings where the happy couple walked that road alone, or had friends and other family members at their side instead.

Your wedding, your choice, end of story.

Sadly, for most people, the story doesn't actually end there. Even though it is logical that the happy couple should be the only people deciding what happens at their wedding, it doesn't mean that other people will respect or accept it.

Advertisement

  • That is what happened in the story below.

    The bride's wish was to either walk down the aisle with her mom or by herself. That was until her sister demanded that the person who should walk her down the aisle be none other than her own fiancé. A guy the bride barely even knows.

    When the bride refused, a family dispute ensued. Keep scrolling to read the full tale.

  • 01
    "I would rather walk down the aisle alone"
    via Oleksandr113

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • 02

    WIBTA if I told my older sister her fiancé isn’t family enough to walk me down the aisle?

    1 (28F) am getting married next spring. It's a small ceremony, mostly family. My dad pa sed away five years ago, and I've been planning to walk down the
    via StarlitHearthJotter
  • 03
    aisle alone or with my mom. My sister (33F) recently got engaged to a guy she's been dating for about a year. He's nice enough, but we're not close. He's never
    via StarlitHearthJotter
  • 04
    tried to bond with me, and honestly, I still feel like I'm getting to know him. Last week, my sister pulled me aside and said she had a "beautiful idea" for my
    via StarlitHearthJotter
  • 05
    wedding: she wants her fiancé to walk me down the aisle. She said it would be "symbolic," like he's stepping into the role our dad left behind, and it
    via StarlitHearthJotter
  • 06
    would "show unity" between our families. I was stunned. I told her I appreciated the thought, but I didn't feel comfortable with it. He's not my dad.
    via StarlitHearthJotter
  • 07
    He's not even my brother- in-law yet. I barely know him. I said I'd rather walk alone or with my mom. She got upset. Said I was "rejecting her future
    via StarlitHearthJotter
  • 08
    husband" and "missing a chance to honor Dad's memory." She even implied. that I was being cold and selfish for not letting someone "step up" when I
    via StarlitHearthJotter
  • 09
    needed support. Now my mom's caught in the middle, and my sister keeps. sending me articles about "chosen family" and "symbolic gestures." I feel
    via StarlitHearthJotter
  • 10
    like I'm being guilted into something deeply personal. I don't want to make a scene, but I also don't want to fake a moment that doesn't feel right.
    via StarlitHearthJotter
  • 11
    WIBTA if I stood my ground and said no?
    via StarlitHearthJotter
  • 12
    Cheezburger Image 10539741696
    via Neustockimages

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • 13
    eeyorethechaotic NTA this is just bizarre. It's perfectly reasonable to expect to plan your own wedding.
    via eeyorethechaotic
  • 14
    BerneDoodleLover24 NTA - just walk alone. Nobody has to give you away". Or walk with your Mom. What your sister suggestiv is not honoring your Dads memories, that is. It would be different, if you were close.
    via BerneDoodleLover24
  • 15
    Fresh Traffic_8186 Did you suggest your husband walk her down the aisle when she gets married??
    via Fresh_Traffic_8186
  • 16
    Spiritual_Oil_7411 NTA how is that honoring your dad? They never even met each other.
    via Spiritual_Oil_7411
  • 17
    Kebar8 Your mum walking you down the aisle is a beautiful idea
    via Kebar8
  • 18
    Snowy Mizz No, not at all. That's a deeply personal moment, and you have the right to choose who shared it with you. It's YOUR wedding and if your sister's fiancé doesn't feel right fitting that role, then it doesn't feel right.
    via SnowyMizz
  • 19
    dlirius14 ΝΤΑ Say no. Make it weird. Ask if she calls him "Daddy".
    via dlirius14
  • 20
    April Danc3r Splendid! Ask her as her fiance is stepping into your dad's shoes whether he'll help pay for the wedding. That's what dads do, right? Absolutely NTA!
    via AprilDanc3r

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

family drama aita bride mother siblings reddit story aisle parenting wedding family sister fiancé Reddit women parents children Father
Scroll Down For The Next Article