Woman ends 3-year relationship after her partner adopts a kitten with no preparations and then decides to return it during a crisis: ‘I personally believe that adopting an animal is a serious commitment.’

Author image for Ayala Sorotsky
Ayala Sorotsky • Writer and Editor
Mar 21, 2026 1:00 PM EDT

When your partner reaches such a debilitating state that they can't take care of the kitten they decided to adopt - we wholeheartedly support the decision to break up with them.

Look, we're not relationship advisers, but if there's one thing we do know we have some sort of expertise about, it's cats. We're not only the people who bring the online cat community their daily dose of feline funnies, and we're not just mere humans whose hearts flutter over the cutest Cat Distribution System stories that we rush to share with you. We're cat people through and through - we love cats, and we know a thing or two about them (to say the least). We're not "working in internet cats" by accident.

So when we hear about a person making a kitten's life difficult, our veins could boil. It's a known fact that cats like stability - in fact, they thrive in predictability and a stable territory they can call home. Sure, there are many more factors to a cat's happiness, but this is the basics, the 101. So if you're a person who decides to adopt a kitten only to give it back, making the smol floof's life difficult - and we're in a relationship with you - we'd also break things up. This is a color to their character that we see as a red flag. So no, we're not relationship advisers, but we're sure as fluff unrelenting cat lovers.

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to start your Caturday with the funniest felines on the internet!

Advertisement
  • 01
    long term reader, first time poster I (28F) recently broke up with my partner (27NB) of almost 3 years and I'm struggling with whether I reached my limit unfairly or if the relationship dynamic had become not compatible My partner has struggled with significant anxiety throughout our relationship.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 02
    It affects a lot of areas of daily life like, household chores, food safety/OCD around cooking, grocery shopping,anxiety about getting sick, and other things.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 03
    For most of our relationship I've tried to be supportive and step in where needed. The issue is that I work a very physically demanding blue-collar job with long hours, and lately I've been feeling overwhelmed.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 04
    I've been asking them to help more around the house because I feel like I'm carrying most of the responsibility emotionally, mentally, and physically.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 05
    A recent example: they had friends coming over and did most of the cleaning beforehand.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 06
    I asked them to handle the living room. They waited until the last minute and didn't finish everything I asked, and we ended up arguing about something as small as emptying the vacuum.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 07
    Whats weighing on me is that it feels less like I'm supporting someone with anxiety and more like my life is being run and controlled by their anxiety.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 08
    A woman sitting alone on a park bench, leaning forward, her head held in her hand. She has an exasperated expression. The picture is diluted and the atmosphere is grey.
    via SB Arts Media

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

    A woman sitting alone on a park bench, leaning forward, her head held in her hand. She has an exasperated expression. The picture is diluted and the atmosphere is grey.

  • 09
    The breaking point happened this week with a kitten. My partner had been talking about wanting a kitten for months.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 10
    They saved money, researched pet insurance, and were really excited about it. I already have a cat, and I made it clear that this kitten would primarily be their responsibility.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 11
    An orange kitten is lying on a grey blanket.
    via Leo Malsam

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

    An orange kitten is lying on a grey blanket.

  • 12
    Shortly after getting the kitten, my partner got sick and their anxiety spiraled. They were anxious about being sick, couldn't sleep because the kitten was active at night, and were struggling to eat due to anxiety.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 13
    I helped during that time, feeding the kitten, playing with it, cleaning up after it, and helping care for my partner.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 14
    I was actually starting to bond with the kitten too. Then on Wednesday they told me they had decided to return the kitten.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 15
    I personally believe that adopting an animal is a serious commitment and shouldn't be taken lightly.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746

  • We wholeheartedly agree witht his statement! And we're definitely not surprised it comes from someone who's already a cat pawrent, who knows the responsibility needed to care for an animal. It's taking care of another soul with needs, feelings, and a whole life of their own - which you're committed to be responssible for.

    Also, a person who sees this in the adopted kitten. We're not surprised that someone who sees the lack of commitment and responsibility for another living being (a precious cat, of all things) as a red flag, has a moral compass guiding them away from that person. Long-lasting relationship or not - the moment your moral compass doesn't allow you to align yourself with your partner's actions, it's probably time to go. And when it comes to morality and cats, as cat pawrents, we know the cat comes first.

  • 16
    A black kitten on a fluffy blanket, looking at something out of frame.
    via luckat

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

    A black kitten on a fluffy blanket, looking at something out of frame.

  • 17
    They admitted they didn't really think through the long- term responsibility before adopting it. When it came time to return the kitten, I didn't go with them.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 18
    I needed emotional space because I disagreed with the decision and felt frustrated that this situation happened at all.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 19
    When they got back, we ended up breaking up. It felt like everything I had been bottling up came out at once.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 20
    A woman covering her ears with her hands, with an anxious expression. The environment is dark and jittery, anxiety-inducing.
    via Nathan Marcam from Pexels

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

    A woman covering her ears with her hands, with an anxious expression. The environment is dark and jittery, anxiety-inducing.

  • 21
    For me, the kitten situation made me start thinking about the future marriage, kids, a house and whether I would always have to carry the emotional and weight in those situations if their anxiety will always take control of major decisions.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 22
    My partner told me they wished I had been more empathetic and verbally supportive during this situation, but from my perspective I was already showing support through actions (helping them when they were sick, taking care of the kitten, etc.).
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 23
    They also told me that their anxiety is part of who they are and they deserve to be loved as they are.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 24
    I agree with that in principle, but I also feel like it's reasonable to want a partner who actively works on coping mechanisms so the relationship doesn't become one sided and resentful.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 25
    So AITAH for reaching a breaking point over this? AITAH and not understanding anxiety? - They are in therapy but not for anxiety specifically - I have talked about how i felt multiple times - I discussed coping mechanisms - we discussed couples therapy if there's a way we can change the dynamic or if we're just simply not compatible.
    via Specific-Sundae-9746
  • 26
    A grey kitten seats and the corner of a couch, his expression is sad and worried.
    via yagmradam

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

    A grey kitten seats and the corner of a couch, his expression is sad and worried.

  • 27
    JeanCerise NTA. We all have our breaking point.
    via JeanCerise

  • That's very true. All people have their breaking points. Mostly, when it comes to morality clashes, when we're talking about relationships. A person who values the well-being of a kitten, who was supposed to be taken care of by their partner, who in turn throws all the responsibility into the bin, is definitely a valid breaking point. We'd probably feel the same.

  • 28
    NTA Caspian4136 Their excuse that anxiety is part of who they are is very much them not wanting to take accountability for it at all. There is plenty out there for people to deal with anxiety, from therapy, medication and learning coping strategies that work best for them. You said they're in therapy but not for anxiety, which is just f ed up. It seems they've grown accustomed to you carrying the mental and physical load for the house and were content to skate by because "anxiety".
    via Caspian4136
  • 29
    When are they ever there for you? It gets exhausting when you're the one who is always there for someone. After 3 years you've seen that they don't really want to manage their anxiety or much else for that matter (such as basic cleaning). This isn't love. This is you being the parent to your partner.
    via Caspian4136
  • 30
    Impressive Moment786 NTA-you aren't being unreasonable. And you don't need a good reason to break up with someone. You can break up for any reason at all.
    via Impressive_Moment786
  • 31
    confused-destiny NTA, I'm gonna be honest, anxiety isn't an excuse. Plenty of people in this world have enough accountability and responsbility despite having crippling anxiety. They live independent, fulfilling lives when they take action to control it. This is frankly a labor digger. When someone just blames everything on their disorder without any real effort, you know they have started using it as an excuse. Good for you OP, please stay away from them.
    via confused-destiny
  • 32
    Dry-Judgment4402 NAH tentatively. You aren't required to stay in a relationship with anyone for any reason.
    via Dry-Judgment4402
  • 33
    NTA Dragons_on_Parade (Apologies for the length) Here's the thing, them saying that anxiety is a part of who they are is both true AND a bit of a cop out. I live with moderate to severe generalized anxiety with the delightful addition of PTSD. I have things that can set me off and when it's bad, it can get pretty bad.
    via Dragons_on_Parade
  • 34
    That being said, while support is very important, it is ultimately my job to ensure that my anxiety doesn't become a mechanism for avoiding self responsibility. You are not their parent and it sounds like they have grown accustomed to just letting you take on everything that might even possibly bring up a negative feeling for them.
    via Dragons_on_Parade
  • 35
    This is avoidant behavior and actually can be more detrimental to anxiety in the long run. We need to be able to practice distress tolerance. Obviously sometimes it's unavoidable that something is truly just too much, but treating everything that MIGHT overwhelm them as something to hide from is just feeding the monster.
    via Dragons_on_Parade
  • 36
    You are not TA for reaching a breaking point over their flippant treatment of another life. Pets are hard, that is a fact, especially when they're babies. My dog absolutely contributed to more than one panic attack of mine when she was a pup.
    via Dragons_on_Parade
  • 37
    However, you make a commitment when you bring them home, and treating them like an accessory that you take back to the store when they're no longer just a cute face is absolutely something I would leave someone over as well, and they would get very little empathy or verbal support from me in that choice.
    via Dragons_on_Parade
  • 38
    The way they have treated you sounds unkind and unfair, and I hope you find some peace in being single right now.
    via Dragons_on_Parade
  • 39
    USAR1981 NTA sometimes we just have to say enough is enough!
    via USAR1981
  • 40
    NTA whatthefrelll Sounds more like a caretaker dynamic than a relationship tbh. You should be able to rely on your SO to take care of you of course, but it should ideally go both ways.
    via whatthefrelll
  • 41
    melli_milli This makes me frustrated to even read, I dunno how you lasted this long! People with mental health issues can definetly be a good partner as long as THEY take the responcibility for their illness. Sometimes you cannot help it and have a bad time. But most of the time it is on you to find help and coping methods. Your partner cannot be your therapist nor parent nor baby sitter.
    via melli_milli
  • 42
    She enjoyed you enabling her helpnessnes. I would call it... What is the word for someone who pretends they cannot do things just for others to do them? Learned incompetence, dunno, but that. Also, I fully get the kitten being the boiling point. Is she even trying to be an adult?
    via melli_milli

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

cat relationship adoption drama cat adoption kitten relationships breakup Cats anxiety
Scroll Down For The Next Article