32-year-old sister-in-law pretends she was fired after quitting her job to move in with brother, gets kicked out when wife discovers the truth: ‘‘She didn't want to have an irresponsible reputation but still wants to stay with us to "sort things out."’

Author image for Etai Eshet
Etai Eshet • Editor
Feb 22, 2025 9:00 PM EST

Some people have a truly remarkable ability to turn everyday life into pure fiction, weaving themselves into tragic heroes in stories no one asked for. Every bad decision becomes a forced hand, and every consequence is rebranded as undeserved suffering. These are not just your run-of-the-mill mistakes—they're performances, complete with villains, plot twists, and, of course, a steady demand for sympathy.  

Why admit to quitting your job when you could create a tale of unjust layoffs that tugs at your family's heartstrings? Why ask politely for help when you can spin a heartbreaking narrative? The best in the game rely on these stories, expertly masking irresponsibility and setting the stage for others to carry their burdens. 

Take this particular star of the stage. After voluntarily leaving her job, she launched a full production about losing it, moving into a family member's home under the guise of desperation. But the moment someone poked a hole in her story, a casual truth dropped by a coworker, she didn't panic. She didn't even flinch. She broke character with a shrug and the ease of someone who thinks the game is already won.

Advertisement

  • "AITA for refusing to let my sister-in-law move in after lying about losing her job?"

    "She betrayed our trust, and we were justified in asking her to leave"
    via mediaphotos

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • Sure, she lied, but she’d still like to stay until things sort themselves out. This bold mix of entitlement and nonchalance is many things: It’s shameless, it’s audacious, and yes, it’s a little impressive.

  • So, background: I (29F) have a sister-in-law, "Melanie" (32F), who's been kind of. difficult. She's always been dramatic, but things have been worse lately. A few weeks ago, she told us that she got fired and was having money problems. She begged my
    via Bluelockfanatiic
  • husband (28M) and me if she might come and stay with us until she was better off. We've helped her before, so we agreed - but under the proviso that she would go out and seek work and do what she could for us while staying with us. She seemed to be really down on her luck, so we agreed.
    via Bluelockfanatiic
  • The problem was, after she'd moved in, everything started to look fishy. She was still going out with friends every other weekend and blowing money on clothes, takeout, and all sorts of other things that didn't add up if she
    via Bluelockfanatiic
  • Cheezburger Image 10471015168
    via Dean Drobot

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • was really in as much financial difficulty as she said she was. My husband and I were getting suspicious about it, but we didn't want to accuse her of anything until we were absolutely sure.
    via Bluelockfanatiic
  • Well, last week, I ran into one of my old coworkers who works for the same company Melanie claimed she'd been laid off from. I inquired about her well-being, and this person told me that
    via Bluelockfanatiic
  • Melanie hadn't been laid off whatsoever! It turned out that she'd actually quit working there weeks earlier to reach out to us, and nobody had any idea why she was making up this story.
    via Bluelockfanatiic
  • I quarreled with Melanie about it, and she admitted that she had quit her job but did not want to admit that to us because she did not want to have an irresponsible
    via Bluelockfanatiic
  • reputation. She said that she was too embarrassed to tell the truth, but she still wanted to stay with us to "sort things out."
    via Bluelockfanatiic
  • I told her to leave. I'm upset because she deceived us, took advantage of our hospitality, and to be honest, I don't appreciate being manipulated like that. My husband is backing me up, but
    via Bluelockfanatiic
  • now his family is giving me such a hard time, calling me heartless and unsympathetic. They say I should have been more sympathetic and that I'm overreacting.
    via Bluelockfanatiic
  • I believe that she betrayed our trust, and we were justified in asking her to leave. But now I'm wondering if maybe I should have handled it differently. AITA for not allowing her to stay after the lie?
    via Bluelockfanatiic
  • SheCantbelieveit His family has an opinion and a place she can stay. NTA.
    via SheCantbelieveit
  • glimmerseeker His family thinks you should be more sympathetic to what?! She LIED about being fired, quit her job, to be able to move in with you and
    via glimmerseeker
  • your husband. If they're so worried about her they can take her in. (They won't.) You're NTA. Good thing you and your husband agree.
    via glimmerseeker
  • Grandmapatty64 Tell anyone that says your heartless that they are free to open their home to her. It doesn't have to be you and your husband. There's more members of the family and she can sponge off with somebody else.
    via Grandmapatty64
  • wild-druid OP, you are NTA. I really think that spouses should manage their own side of the family during ordeals like this. It is your husband's sister. You guys
    via wild-druid
  • made the decision to help together, but primarily contact to remove the SIL should've been handled by your spouse as it is his sister.
    via wild-druid
  • makeitmakesense2023 NTA-if her family is so disappointed then maybe it's their turn to step up and step in? Funny how people who aren't doing anything always seem to have the most to say.
    via makeitmakesense2023
  • Fickle_Toe1724 NTA. She quit her job, then lied about it. She can go stay with anyone who says you should keep her.
    via Fickle_Toe1724
  • I grew up with the idea of, you never quit a job until you have another one lined up. Take a day off to do interviews, yes. But you don't quit until you have the start date for the new job.
    via Fickle_Toe1724
  • Any-Split3724 Every guest room should be outfitted with a mother-in- law mattress (so uncomfortable and hard they can't stay more than 3 days). She's gotten comfy
    via Any-Split3724
  • and buried herself into your home like the bloodsucker tick that she is. Your husband needs to man up and give her walking papers. Time for her to leech off someone rise.
    via Any-Split3724
  • Cheezburger Image 10471015424
    via TatyanaGl

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

Tags

family drama inheritance aita AITAH brother mother tradition siblings family feud favoritism wedding aunt sister fiancé grandmother Father
Scroll Down For The Next Article