Relationship of 8 years ends when boyfriend ruins girlfriend’s birthday and disrespects her brother: “I thought I’d be sad about us breaking up, but I’m not”

Author image for Briana Viser
Briana Viser • Writer and Editor
Apr 23, 2025 12:00 PM EDT

Welcome back ladies and gentlemen. Birthdays mean a lot to some people. Some people don't even tell their friends they're having a birthday, while others don't stop talking about it for months beforehand. At the end of the day it isn't about a "birthday" per se, but that the person wants to feel loved, appreciated, and valued by the people surrounding them. Maybe most of the year they feel neglected and don't know how to speak up about it, and their birthday is their one day a year where it's socially acceptable to be narcissistic. 

Besides birthdays, being in a relationship and having a birthday could be one of the best memories you two have together, or a terrible nightmare. Maybe your partner did something really extravagant, he/she went above and beyond to make your birthday extra special. I remember one year my boyfriend and I went to Thailand for my birthday, and he rented a hotel room at a private resort. We spent the day adventuring outside, hiking, climbing down into lagoons, and it was definitely special. 

In the story below, the boyfriend falls a bit flat of giving his girlfriend a special birthday. But you'll have to read the full story below for all the juicy details. 

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • 01

    AITAH for leaving my boyfriend of 8 years, after he ruined my birthday and told my brother that he needed to change his clothes?

    Happy Birthday
    via RyanKing999 / Canva

    This image is for illustration only, and the subjects are models; the image does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 02
    I, 30f, have been with my bf (now ex-boyfriend) 36m, for eight years. He knows everything about me and he knows my family, but I never expected him to behave the way that he did. Let me start at the beginning:
    via u/QueenieB_

  • It's crazy to me that they made it this far in their relationship. They seem like a very young and immature couple. I guess the girl was only 22 when they started dating. I think this kind of thing tends to happen when you start dating so young, you get sort of stuck in that age range. 

  • 03
    Yesterday was my birthday and we had made plans to spend the day together. We were going to go shopping and out to eat because I wanted to keep things small and simple this year. He lives about an hour and a half away from me and told me to call him when I woke up, so he could come down early. I
    via u/QueenieB_
  • 04
    woke up at 9am and immediately texted him, before getting ready for the day and going to run some errands. I kid you not, this man had me waiting ALL DAY for him. I texted him again at 12pm, asking when he was coming, and he said that he had to "finish his laundry." I didn't mind that, so I said okay.
    via u/QueenieB_
  • 05
    He called me around 1pm and we usually sit on the phone for hours, talking or doing other things, and we did that until about 4pm. By that time, I was getting upset because we had plans and I had been waiting on him all day. Fast forward to about 8pm, and he FINALLY shows up. It's clear he's upset, but so was I. I hadn't eaten all day and I was hungry.
    via u/QueenieB_
  • 06
    Now, I invited my siblings to come, and this is where the problem happened. My younger brother, 21m, is openly gay and has his own sense of fashion. If I can remember clearly, he was wearing shorts, a crop top, and a top over his shirt so that you really couldn't tell that he was wearing a crop top. And I
    via u/QueenieB_
  • 07
    should also mention that the shorts weren't super short either. He dresses like that daily and I didn't see a problem with it. If I'm being honest, he had on more clothes than I did.
    via u/QueenieB_
  • 08
    My boyfriend saw him and didn't say anything. We all got into the car and headed to the restaurant, but halfway there...he turned the car around and said he wasn't going into a restaurant with my brother dressed the way that he was. He then told him that he had to change his clothes, and that
    via u/QueenieB_
  • 09
    made my brother uncomfortable and upset. He told my boyfriend to pull over so he could get out of the car, and I said no. It was in the middle of the night, on a dark back road, and I wasn't letting him get out of the car.
    via u/QueenieB_
  • 10
    I didn't understand what the issue was all of a sudden, especially when he clearly saw my brother's outfit before we left the house, but I was pred off and I knew right then and there...I was done with this relationship. When we got back to my house, I told him we were done, and he said he was fine with
    via u/QueenieB_
  • 11
    that before leaving. I thought I'd be sad about us breaking up, but I'm not. It was a long time coming, but now everyone is saying that I was too hasty in my decision to break up with him. So, AITAH?
    via u/QueenieB_
  • 12
    Edit: I need to also clarify that my ex knew my brother was gay the whole time we were together, and never had a problem with it. My wording was off, but what I meant was that his hidden homophobia had come to the surface. Not once had he ever expressed his dislike for my brother or became hostile towards him like he did last night.
    via u/QueenieB_
  • 13
    ClaraBerries 12h ago • not the ah at all. he ruined your birthday, disrespected your brother, and made everything about himself. you just finally chose peace over tolerating that mess.
    via u/ClaraBerries
  • 14
    Adri668 • 12h ago Move on. He was looking for an excuse to end it
    via u/Adri668
  • 15
    Cheezburger Image 10496473088
    via Phoebe Yu / Canva

    This image is for illustration only, and the subjects are models; the image does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 16
    Sebscreen 12h ago • NTA. I'm puzzled at how it even got that bad even before his completely out of line remarks about your brother. You spoke
    via u/Sebscreen
  • 17
    in the phone for 3 hours but he never understood that you wanted him to come down ASAP? And you starved yourself all day despite having no confirmation that he was joining you till dinner?
    via u/Sebscreen
  • 18
    giorgiamazingfu • 12h ago NTA but I wonder: during those 8 years together there was never a similar behavior? Are you sure there isn't something wrong with him?
    via u/giorgiamazingfu
  • 19
    Ok-Somewhere911 • 12h ago I mean it doesn't sound like he was that bothered that you ended it so it was clearly the right choice.
    via u/Ok-Somewhere911
  • 20
    Zestyclose-Height-36 12h ago • Nta. He didn't want to be there, and was enough of an ah to get you to do the breaking up ON YOUR BIRTHDAY.
    via u/Zestyclose-Height-36
  • 21
    badatcreatingnames • 12h ago He was picking a fight so that you would be the one to end it so that he can play victim after while he enjoys the freedom he was actually looking for. This is such classic behavior. You are well rid of him, NTA of course.
    via u/badatcreatingnames
  • 22
    Cheezburger Image 10496473600
    via Manish Dhodi from Pexels / Canva

    This image is for illustration only, and the subjects are models; the image does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 23
    Y2Flax 11h ago • How about the fact that you spent 3 hours on the phone without him saying when he was arriving. This is so strange
    via u/Y2Flax
  • 24
    Funkster 1965 • 12h ago NTA he was r de and insensitive. Be done
    via u/Funkster 1965
  • 25
    • Gatodeluna 11h ago It sounds like he wanted to break up with you so he deliberately created a scenario where you'd be pushed to break up with him and he could say he 'doesn't get it' and be the injured party.
    via u/Gatodeluna
  • 26
    Monday0987 .7h ago but now everyone is saying that I was too hasty in my decision to break up with him Who? Who is saying that?
    via u/Monday0987

Tags

boyfriend drama birthday relationships girlfriend lol couples love breakup reddit thread Reddit funny dating
Scroll Down For The Next Article