22-year-old college student got dumped by his 21-year-old girlfriend simply for talking to a female friend: ‘From my girlfriend's perspective, she believes: I hid important information.’

Author image for Olivia Arocena
Olivia Arocena • Writer and Editor
Jun 14, 2026 9:45 AM EDT

Are we expected to handle what somebody else feels for us?

I wish someone or something could protect us from the ridiculous fights we pick and the mistakes we make in our first relationships, but we are at the mercy of stronger forces and find ourselves pushed to go through that character arc alone. Everything feels so dramatic when we're in our early twenties; you couldn't pay me enough to go back, but no one can take the pleasure of watching and analyzing someone who's still in the trenches away from me. At any rate, we're gathered around this virtual fire today to pick this Redditor's story apart and extract every possible drop of its delicious juice. Well, I guess you'll be the judges of its deliciousness.

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • A boy and two girls hug and smile together
    via Alexander Mass

    Three models representing the guy in our story, his girlfriend, and his female friend.

  • [22M] My girlfriend [21F] broke up with me after reading chats with my female friend [24F]. Did I betray her trust?

    I'm a college student and recently went through a breakup. I'm looking for honest outside opinions because I'm struggling to understand whether I crossed a line or whether this was mainly a misunderstanding.
    via Luvboi004
  • Before I got into a relationship with my girlfriend, I had a very close female friend whom I met online. Over time we became extremely close. She cared about me a lot, supported me emotionally, and even helped me financially during difficult periods of my life.
    via Luvboi004
  • When I started dating my girlfriend, I told her about this friend. I never hid her existence, and my friend also knew about my relationship. In fact, my friend generally encouraged my relationship and often gave me advice whenever I had problems with my girlfriend.
    via Luvboi004
  • However, after some time, my female friend developed romantic feelings for me and eventually confessed that she loved me.
    via Luvboi004
  • This is where I think I may have made mistakes.
    via Luvboi004
  • Although I did not return those feelings and wanted to stay with my girlfriend, I also didn't end my friendship with my friend. I felt guilty because she had done so much for me and I didn't want to abandon her. So I continued talking to her as a close friend.
    via Luvboi004
  • I also never told my girlfriend that my friend had confessed her feelings. I was afraid that revealing it would create problems, make my girlfriend uncomfortable, and hurt everyone involved.
    via Luvboi004
  • Over time my friend herself decided to create distance because she felt her feelings might eventually become a problem for my relationship. She repeatedly told me that my happiness with my girlfriend mattered more than anything else.
    via Luvboi004
  • A few days ago, after trying to distance herself, she texted me saying that she missed me and was struggling with the separation.
    via Luvboi004
  • On the same day, my girlfriend saw our chats and also saw screenshots I had saved from earlier conversations.
    via Luvboi004
  • One of the screenshots included my friend saying "I love you."
    via Luvboi004
  • My girlfriend also saw a message where I had described my friend as someone who cared for me "like an elder sister." She now believes I lied because my friend actually had romantic feelings for me.
    via Luvboi004

  • The expectation to control somebody else’s feelings is a bit delu-lu, but one could argue that our partners should try to avoid possible future messy situations and push jealousy or desire away from them while they are in a relationship, but this particular entanglement has its lights and shadows. In the comments, other Redditors say that the guy’s biggest mistake was not telling his girlfriend that his best friend had confessed her feelings for him right when it happened, and that precisely that omission later created a secrecy that became suspicious.

  • I hear that a lot in my friends’ relationship drama, and I read that a lot while I’m scrolling through Reddit: secrets make relationships tremble. Truth is, we should be able to have our privacy and things we don’t share with our partners. In this particular case, what could go wrong? Really, if he is not interested in the other girl and never was, and if the case is that he only wants to keep a very important friendship.

  • From my girlfriend's perspective, she believes: I hid important information. I allowed another girl who loved me to stay emotionally close to me.
    via Luvboi004
  • My friend and I had something. going on before or during the relationship. She was made to believe my friend was more like family while the reality was different.
    via Luvboi004
  • From my perspective: I never had romantic feelings for my friend. I never intended to leave my girlfriend for her. I told both people about each other's existence.
    via Luvboi004
  • My friend knew I loved my girlfriend and repeatedly supported the relationship. I hid the confession because I thought it would only create pain and conflict.
    via Luvboi004
  • After seeing everything, my girlfriend immediately broke up with me, blocked me everywhere, and refuses any further discussion.
    via Luvboi004

  • Just like this guy’s actions were a little bit messy, relationships in general are, and we don’t act as rationally as we would like to: we go through phones, we become extremely hurt by things that objectively weren’t that important, and we hide things from our significant others just out of fear that if they find out, they might not love us anymore.

  • What makes this especially difficult for me is that I genuinely want to fix things. I'm willing to answer every question honestly, show any chats, accept responsibility for my mistakes, and do whatever is necessary to rebuild trust. However, my girlfriend does not want any conversation at all and has completely cut off contact.
    via Luvboi004
  • I understand that hiding the confession may have been wrong. I also understand that continuing such a close friendship after learning about my friend's feelings may have crossed boundaries.
    via Luvboi004
  • From an outside perspective, would you consider this emotional cheating, a serious breach of trust, poor boundaries, or mainly a misunderstanding?
    via Luvboi004
  • If you were in my girlfriend's position, would you have ended the relationship immediately? Is there any realistic way to rebuild trust when one person refuses all communication?
    via Luvboi004
  • two people holding a black papercut heart
    via Kelly Sikkema

    a picture representing matters of the heart being so difficult

  • The girl in this story, sadly, ended the relationship on the spot, and he was left to pick up the pieces and to try to learn from the experience. Personally, I'm left wishing they could sort it out, but this looks more like a ‘personal growth after a breakup’ situation to me. At any rate, the guy is doing the right thing by reflecting on his actions. We’re left to wonder here what the ex-girlfriend’s side of the story is….

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

relationship advice relationships toxic relationship
Scroll Down For The Next Article

Also From FAIL Blog

Grandchild spends months arranging to buy grandmother's garden, cousin suddenly changes his mind and claims it for himself: 'Why hasn't he done anything to acquire it before?'

Grandchild spends months arranging to buy grandmother's garden, cousin suddenly changes his mind and claims it for himself: 'Why hasn't he done anything to acquire it before?'

Trending Now

Manteinance employee maliciously complies with his manager's new rule and in an unexpected turn of events, his manager loves it: 'As you can tell from the title, this did not go how I was expecting'

Manteinance employee maliciously complies with his manager's new rule and in an unexpected turn of events, his manager loves it: 'As you can tell from the title, this did not go how I was expecting'

01
Frustrated gym user sets up an automatic response for every time he gets a late fee notification in revenge for the one time they charged him an extra $11: 'I did what anyone with too much free time and a mild interest in how systems work would do'

Frustrated gym user sets up an automatic response for every time he gets a late fee notification in revenge for the one time they charged him an extra $11: 'I did what anyone with too much free time and a mild interest in how systems work would do'

02
Chef thinks he is teaching the kitchen "Runner" a lesson over a kitchen intrusion, but he's the one who learns one thanks to the Runner's malicious compliance: 'Don't want me to do the work? Ok, then do it yourself'

Chef thinks he is teaching the kitchen "Runner" a lesson over a kitchen intrusion, but he's the one who learns one thanks to the Runner's malicious compliance: 'Don't want me to do the work? Ok, then do it yourself'

03
Employee is told by boss to stop being chatty and friendly, she complies, rumors about her being in a bad state of mind start to rise: 'The following week, the director called me into her office and asked what was wrong".

Employee is told by boss to stop being chatty and friendly, she complies, rumors about her being in a bad state of mind start to rise: 'The following week, the director called me into her office and asked what was wrong".

04
Sister changes her house lock to avoid his brother moving in with her, her parents make a huge drama implying it's her duty, and gave him a key anyway: 'I had the exterior locks changed and did not give my parents another key.'

Sister changes her house lock to avoid his brother moving in with her, her parents make a huge drama implying it's her duty, and gave him a key anyway: 'I had the exterior locks changed and did not give my parents another key.'

05
IT fails to fix employee's computer, leading to their account and login being deleted, employee spends over two weeks unable to work: ‘What a clown show’

IT fails to fix employee's computer, leading to their account and login being deleted, employee spends over two weeks unable to work: ‘What a clown show’

06
Advertisement