Father’s Day visit goes wrong after dad compares it to the effort his daughter made for Mother’s Day: ‘She got up and drove home’

Author image for Celeste Mello
Celeste Mello • Writer and Editor
Jun 25, 2026 10:30 AM EDT

When the relationship between a father and a daughter is a little strained, that tension can come to the surface during a family holiday like Father's Day. You can't expect everything to feel normal if the relationship has been rocky lately. At the same time, this special day comes with expectations. Every father wants to feel appreciated on Father's Day. 

But it is not reasonable to expect the same warmth and celebration if you know your relationship hasn't been in the best place lately. Still, despite this, his daughter showed up, drove an hour to see him, and spent time with her dad. Maybe she was not as warm as he hoped, and maybe she did seem more distant, and that can hurt. But considering their recent arguments about her career, it isn't shocking that she wasn't acting as if everything was fine. Sometimes, as a parent, you have to appreciate what your daughter can give you at the moment and understand what the relationship is going through. His daughter showing up when things had been complicated is really meaningful. She could have skipped the day, but she didn't. 

This also could have been a good opportunity for him to reflect on why things were different, see what had happened, and see what he could change to make things better between them. Instead of taking that approach, this father was so hurt by his daughter's attitude on Father's Day that he had no better idea than to complain to her. He ended up comparing her behavior to what she did for Mother's Day, which, by the way, was completely unrelated to their relationship. That was never going to lead to a productive conversation.

If the dad wants a closer relationship with his daughter, the better approach would be to stop keeping score and start listening. Comparing the celebrations only made the unresolved hurt in their relationship even worse. What parents forget is that, to feel appreciated on important days, they first have to make their children feel supported.

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • 01
    An illustration of a father greeting a daughter who drove 1 hour to visit him on Father's Day.
    via Unsplash+ (Getty Images)

    An illustration of a father greeting a daughter who drove 1 hour to visit him on Father's Day.

  • 02

    AITA for mentioning to my daughter that she did more for Mother's Day?

    My wife and I (53m) have one kid, a daughter (25f) who lives an hour away and drove over to "celebrate" Father's Day. We got brunch and walked around a park and spent time together.
    via throwaway336936
  • 03
    We've always had a close relationship but it's been rocky the last year. We've had arguments recently about her career. I'm a lawyer and she enrolled in law school but dropped out in year 3. That's been the source of many arguments.
    via throwaway336936
  • 04
    The whole day today it felt like she was mad at me. I perceived her being cold towards me, with curt answers, not much engagement or warmth, polite smiles.
    via throwaway336936
  • 05
    Everything very distant. She didn't get me any gifts or even a card. She did say "Happy Father's Day" but that was about it.
    via throwaway336936
  • 06
    Law books representing a daughter’s decision to leave law school and the family tension surrounding her career path.
    via Unsplash+ (Krists Luhaers)

    Law books representing a daughter's decision to leave law school and the family tension surrounding her career path.

  • 07
    In contrast for Mother's Day last month, she came for the whole weekend, she took my wife to a massage spa and a nice lunch and dinner, she brought over my wife's favorite baked pie, she got her various small gifts and a nice card.
    via throwaway336936
  • 08
    I don't care about gifts but I do care that she was cold with me on Father's Day. It felt awful. I asked her what was wrong, what I did, if we could please talk, she denied anything was wrong and told me I'm trying to make a big deal out of nothing.
    via throwaway336936
  • 09
    My wife asked me to let it go but denial from my daughter when something was obviously wrong was frustrating. It ended with me bringing up that she did a lot more for Mother's day in comparison to today (to
    via throwaway336936
  • 10
    make the point that obviously she was upset with me). It set her off. She called me 'entitled' and got up and drove home.
    via throwaway336936
  • 11
    My wife got upset by how I handled this. She says I'm the AH in this situation. AITA?
    via throwaway336936
  • 12
    Edit: I never pressured her to go into law. She decided that herself. My wife and I both wanted her to finish the last 5 months of law school just to get the degree, as we'd poured lots of money into it and she was so close to the finish line. We told her not to do law if she's not
    via throwaway336936
  • 13
    happy with it. We just wanted her to get the degree. She quit to become an artist and when I realized she made up her mind, I stopped trying to convince her and did my best to be loving and supportive.
    via throwaway336936
  • 14
    A representation of a father and adult daughter walking through a park during a Father’s Day outing.
    via Unsplash+ (Getty Images)

    A representation of a father and adult daughter walking through a park during a Father's Day outing.

  • 15
    VironLLA YTA. she was there spending time with you & instead of appreciating it you decided it wasn't enough. she drove an hour each way to spend time with you
    via s
  • 16
    Polish_girl44 I dont get what was wrong with Fathers Day and why it should be the same for both parents. This are different relations and dynamics and OP wasnt left without celebaration
    via s
  • 17
    Ok-Walk-8453 YTA for saying she did more for Mother's Day. I understand you were frustrated, but the comment was out of line and parenting is not a competition. If she denies anything is wrong, best thing to do would have been to drop it. Even if something was wrong, she wasn't in a space where she was able to talk about it. The reason she was short may or may not have had anything to do with you- could be unrelated.
    via s
  • 18
    chaserscarlet She spent the whole day with him and kept things polite and civil. He got pred she wasn't acting the way he expected to gift and all. He has every right to be mad she dropped out, he has no right to expect that constantly fighting about it will have no impact to their relationship. -
    via s
  • 19
    roseofjuly Come ON people, this is weak. We all know that "being polite and civil" is below the bare minimum expectation for father's day. She's upset because her father called her out on her monumental selfishness and impulsivity and she's punishing him for it like a child.
    via s
  • 20
    shizzstirer Exactly. Something else is going on. I came out of law school with severe depre son; I can't imagine what would cause someone to drop out at that point. Are you sure you didn't push her to go, even implicitly? It sounds like your wife also wasn't on board with her dropping out, so it's not about just disagreeing.
    via s
  • 21
    7lexliv7 I wonder if she's actually mad at herself for dropping out of law school and is taking it out on her dad.
    via s
  • 22
    AlufryNA YTA. I have a dad like you, and trust me, it's rarely about just one incident. It's usually years of resentment building up over time. At least your daughter is trying to be a better daughter than I ever was. And yeah, effort tends to come naturally when someone feels loved and appreciated. The fact that she goes out of her way for her mom suggests that her mom has created that kind of relationship with her. If she's not putting in the same effort with you, it might be worth reflecting
    via s
  • 23
    chaserscarlet So you've been an unsupportive father and are now surprised she's not going above and beyond to celebrate you on Father's Day? Wow it's almost like actions have consequences huh Edit to add: for all the bot hurt people in the comments - this isn't about whether or not OP had a right to be upset about the daughter dropping out. It's about expecting everything to be normal on Father's Day when your relationship is obviously fractured.
    via s

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

family drama fathers day family stories daughter Father
Scroll Down For The Next Article