Homeowner hosting a family pool day during a heatwave refuses to cook a second meal for his sister's picky kids after already preparing dinner for 20 people: 'I'm not cooking more food than I need to'

Advertisement
Young child sitting at a dining table with an untouched meal, representing picky eating habits and mealtime challenges during family gatherings.
My husband (35M) and I (35M) have 2 kids (8M, 4F). Here in England we are currently experiencing a heatwave, me and my husband are fortunate enough to have a swimming pool so during heatwaves we tend to host a lot of family gatherings just so everybody has a chance to cool off in the pool. We also have AC in our house.
Everybody arrived at about 1pm, we had some snack foods around such as crisps, fruit, vegetables, bread. So everybody was snacking. When it was time to make dinner, I looked at the weekly meal schedule on my fridge and started making the dinner that I had already planned to make today.
I told everybody in advanced what I am making for dinner, just to give them a heads up because I wanted to be polite. Honey bbq chicken salad with a jacket potato and some raw vegetables. Easy dinner for a heatwave. I already knew my kids would love with dinner, so I wasn't too worried.
My sister had 3 kids (9F, 8F, 6M), all 3 of her kids are quite picky eaters. They aren't neurodivergent either, they are just picky eaters. So my sister asked me if I could make them a separate meal, maybe put some chicken nuggets or fishfingers in the air fryer and maybe put some chips in the air fryer too.
I told her that we don't have any of that food in our freezer and I'm not going to the shop to buy those food items, but I'm also not cooking any more meals than I need to. She then asked if I could make some pesto pasta, I said she can make the pasta herself after I've cooked dinner but no I'm not making more food than I already planned.
I was already cooking for like 20 people and that was a lot of stress already, I didn't have the space or time to also cook some pasta. Plus it was also 34° which is really hot for England. Yes we have AC but cooking in the heat is still not fun even when you have AC.
I said dinner is dinner, that's final. There was snacks that her kids would eat such as crisps and bread and fruit, so it's not like her kids would starve cause there was food available.
Everybody left half an hour ago but now my mum is texting me and saying I was wrong to not just accomodate my sisters kids. She said I didn't have to make dinner such a big deal.
Person preparing a homemade meal in a kitchen, representing the effort and responsibility involved in cooking for a large group of guests.
PanAsHeck NTA. They're lucky they got more than cereal in this heat let alone food they didn't cook themselves.
subtlelikeatank NTA. Response to mom: "I also didn't have to feed all of the people who came over to my house, but I did and I didn't hear you offering to help"
Caspian4136 ΝΤΑ If she knows her kids are that picky, she should be bringing her own food. Honestly she should be anyway as she knows there's so many extra people at your house right now.
fascinatedcharacter NTA. You accommodated your sister's kids by offering your kitchen to your sister. Your sister could've brought the chicken nuggets if she'd planned ahead.
LavenderSharpie Sissy should have asked about dinner before arriving and if her kiddos are picky, she is responsible for bringing food they will eat.
Family relaxing beside a backyard swimming pool during warm weather, representing a heatwave gathering hosted for relatives and friends.
Alternative-Pear9096 NTA. If your sister's kids require special food, Sis and BIL (don't forget him) 100% needed to have communicated that need ahead of time and expected to bring the food and cook it themselves. They are all very wrong.
Artistic-Tough-7764 this is the dinner plan. If you want something different you're welcome to bring it. I won't have space for other food prep here. Enjoy the pool time.” NTA
KnowledgeNeed Absolutely NTA. If she was that concerned about having something for her picky eaters to eat; she should either bring it herself or make it herself afterwards. What you'd planned for dinner, for 20 people, sounds delicious and perfect for a summer evening. Have you a recipe to share for the honey bbq chicken?
Shoesietart Why couldn't your sister make the pesto pasta? You had already prepared food for 20 people and she wanted you to then make food for just her kids! Your sister is kind of selfish! And if her kids are such picky eaters, why didn't she bring food for them? Your sister was not a good guest. NTAH.
CharieRarie NTA, if she knows they are picky she can make them lunchboxes. One of my daughters struggles with food, so when we go to someone else's house or go out to eat, I'll pack her a lunchbox with "safe" options. She's always welcome to try other foods, but she's got her lunchbox to fall back on if she can't manage.
withcatlikegrace Welcome to the real world, kids. Very few people are going to accommodate your demands or your innate rudeness. And sister - you and your children are brats ... don't come back until you learn to be polite guests.
TrappedInHyperspace Clearly NTA. There's nothing wrong with the dinner you prepared. Also, I very much hope you made a typo when you wrote that your guests arrived at 1am.

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article