"Don't worry, we just need $15,000 from you": 36-year-old aunt fails to live up to promise to bankroll 15-year-old niece's quinceanera party, family call her stingy when she tries to compromise

Advertisement
  • 01

    AITA for refusing to pay for my niece's "dream quinceañera" even though I promised to help with it two years ago?

    151 "I never said I would bankroll a mini- wedding"
  • 02
    I'm a 36-year-old woman and I make a decent income. I've always tried to be generous with my family. A couple of years ago, my brother, who is 38,
  • 03
    mentioned that his daughter, my niece Jules, was really looking forward to her quinceañera when she turned 15. He was
  • 04
    having a tough time financially, so I casually said something like, "When the time comes, I'd love to pitch in or help however I can."
  • 05
    15
  • 06
    Fast forward to this year, and Jules is about to turn 15. I get hit with a full wedding-style event proposal. My brother and sister-in-law sent me a PDF
  • 07
    presentation, a literal deck, outlining a $23,000 budget. We're talking venue, catering, DJ, designer dress, fireworks, and even a horse-drawn carriage.
  • 08
    I was stunned. I told them I couldn't contribute that much, and they said, "Don't worry. We just need $15k from you." I thought they were joking.
  • 09
    question, When I said that was out of the my brother got defensive and said I "promised" to help and now I was
  • 10
    backing out. I offered $2,000, which I thought was still generous, and said I could help with logistics or DIY decorations.
  • 11
    Now I'm the "stingy aunt" who "crushed Jules's dream." Even my mom called me and said I should have expected this since I "make more than all of us combined."
  • 12
    I feel like they took advantage of my casual offer from two years ago. I never said I would pay for the whole party or bankroll a mini-wedding.AITA for saying no?
  • 13
    S
  • 14
    Beautiful-Report58 Pfffft! It's 2k or nothing. That's the final offer. She can get realistic expectations
  • 15
    or be 1. You could make 10x more than everyone combined, that doesn't give them the right to reach into your pocket.
  • 16
    classygirlcoleen OP I'm not refusing to help, I'm refusing to be taken for granted. My 2k offer was generous, thoughtful, and honest. If
  • 17
    that makes me the villain, maybe they were never really grateful in the first place.
  • 18
    Aylauria It absolutely was. And the fact that her parents didn't put an immediate end to her absurd expectations is their total parenting failure, is not your problem.
  • 19
    You were generous. Now it's time to tell them that in light of their treatment of you, that offer is off the table as well. NTA
  • 20
    Capital-Wolverine532 NTA. I know it's a big deal but it should be party and photo's. Thst hollywpod production proposal is for A listers
  • 21
    classygirlcoleen OP I even offered to throw her a beautiful, heartfelt celebration with music, decorations, and cake. But they weren't after a quinceañera, they wanted a spectacle on someone else's dime.
  • 22
    Cheezburger Image 10533581824
  • 23
    NTA KombuchaBot They're delusional
  • 24
    FairyGothMommy NTA. No 15 year old kid needs a party that costs more than a down payment on a house.
  • 25
    A venue, food, a cake, music. Her dress (which should not be a huge cupcake monstrosity). A DJ.
  • 26
    underratedpossum I agree with everything except I think if the girl wants a (in budget) cupcake- monstosity dress she should have one
  • 27
    Waste_Airport3295 NTA. Girl... my wedding was 10k, which I thought was insane! I was full steam DIY and had extended extended family on
  • 28
    board to assist. Saying you'd help out does not mean you promised a blank check. That's incredibly manipulative.
  • 29
    catinnameonly NTA - You didn't offer to give her they 'dream' experience. You offered to chip in on a 15 yrs old bday party.
  • 30
    I understand the importance. I'm a wedding photographer, but unless her parents are flush. That is an absurd amount to pay for a party when she's only a couple years away from college.
  • 31
    Also what is going to be the expectation of you when she gets married? Did they hit up any other relatives or they trying to only pin it on you.

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article